2 kids pretending to be grown-ups...

Ok, so I know long time no post. But, I only have a few minutes but, I have quick poll for you ALL to take.

My friend is getting engaged and her boyfriend has hired me as the 'consultant' of the proposal. He has two ideas and he is not sure which to do. I have my own favorite but, I want to know what you all think.

Idea #1 Go out to dinner with Ryan and I (so, it would be the 4 of us). The idea of dinner is to totally throw her off guard because she would not expect anything with us there. But, she has expressed to him how she would love for me to be there when she gets engaged. (she's my best friend). Anyways, we would eat dinner at Durant's (if you haven't been there, go!) and of course the waiter would bring her the ring with her dessert.

Idea #2 He would propose in the afternoon (before dinner) when they check into their hotel room. I would have already decorated the room with the flowers and ring of course would already be there.

Obviously, idea #1 would be in front of people but, still surprising. Idea #2 small intimate no one watching. Which would you want?

I know what I would like but, what do you girls all think?